Paranoia — Jewish style, of course
search
Opinion

Paranoia — Jewish style, of course

We Jews are all paranoids. And we should be!

To wit, I was, as were some of you, an adult on November 22, 1963, 63 long years ago. Like anyone else hearing the cataclysmic news of our president’s assassination, my very first response was a bit insane, definitely paranoid. I prayed that the assassin was not Jewish.

I adored JFK, whose news conferences I used to watch whenever possible, and whose button adorned my clothing during his campaign, a huge button that shouted “It Seems to Me It’s Kennedy.” I was of that demographic of liberal young Jews who saw promise and intellect in the handsome young senator from Massachusetts. I envisioned success and charm and the freedom to live our family’s American Jewish life, or is it Jewish American, unburdened by antisemites, in a world of Jewish opportunity in our own USA, with abiding and binding love for the feisty young State of Israel.

Things looked good. I was then a 24-year-young wife, mother of a six-week-old baby girl, a graduate of Newark Rutgers, living in a small Huntington Terrace apartment in Newark’s Weequahic that our little family shared with a pet dog. Our future lives looked safe and sane. Paranoia had no place in my life.

My equally young husband and I reached out to those less fortunate, becoming members of several nonprofits and devoting ourselves to being inclusive of those who practiced other religions and had different national backgrounds. But we knew who we were, and, on that tragic November day, the first thing my man did was walk to the nearby synagogue, a block up the Shephard Avenue hill. We mourned as Americans and as Jews.

So, from whence came that far-fetched notion that the assassin could even remotely possibly be Jewish? And even more, that we Jews would pay any sort of a price if he, in fact, were? Even in my deepest soul I never harbored such dark thoughts. I thought I felt secure in my Jewishness, with a deeply held respect for my people. Yet that fear came to me, as it did to many others, that “what if,” that could possibly impact our Jewish confidence, our sense of belonging, and our safety. Was I truly worried about backlash if the killer was indeed one of us?

Well, the killer, Lee Harvey Oswald, was, as all know, an atheist with no Jewish connections at all, except for his own assassin, a Jew named Jack Ruby. Certainly there was stigma there, but Ruby, ne Rubinstein, was a vanquishing hero. He killed the bad guy, not the good guy. Our American Jewish security remained intact. And my paranoia, which had surfaced unexpectedly, became submerged into undertones once again, not rising in a major way until now.

Today, Jewish history and Jewish paranoia have, yet again, merged and blended. Any student of the past would have anticipated this reincarnation, and even pointed out that it was almost always there, that age-old Jew hatred, pervasive, sometimes cyclical, but usually perennial. Any student of our long history will have no difficulty in winnowing it out.

One thing I learned in the ensuing years, when I transitioned from young adult to very old woman, is that the hatred has never gone away, while it has often been beneath the surface. After all, in whichever society or nation we are part of, we are almost always major contributors to culture, education, science, the highest values of selflessness. We are inclusive people, meaning we join with others to build up the places where we live, sometimes sadly even leaving our own nationalities and religion behind. Most of us, however, remain proud to be Jewish, even though for some, that pride is merely a remnant of our pasts, rather than a goal of our futures.

Yet, surprisingly, as a secure American college-educated young Jew, my primeval fears raced ahead of my brain and shouted at me to be wary, that Lee Harvey Oswald might be a Jew.

Perhaps the way to chart antisemitism is on a graph, to see the dips and heights. In today’s America, and actually throughout the world, it is virulent. The graph would show giant peaks. We are faulted by the left and the right. We cannot rejoice in recent election victories because many of those elected are despicable, as are many of those who lost. This almost indecipherable election has brought to the fore many of our adversaries. Do we rejoice in our victory over the likes of Trump, Vance, Hegseth, RFK Jr., or Miller? Surely, these are those we had hoped to defeat. And we did! Their days in leadership are clearly numbered.

Or do we cringe at the successes of the self-called-so-called progressives, Mamdani, El Sayed, Darializa Avila Chevalier, AOC? Bernie Sanders! I fear them all, and I am undoubtedly justified in that fear. Our enemies come from the right and the left. Tom Lehrer said it clearly when he composed the song that teaches “Everybody Hates the Jews.”

Furthermore, I fear those of our own people who admire and support them, those on the left and those on the right. They are defining a persistent and growing role for far too many Jewish people, the role of self-hating Jews. Many of these people are young, supremely well educated, and frightening, people we need to keep on our team. We see them in the press, most notably in the New York Times, and the Washington Post, and other highly praised newspapers. We see them in academia, at the world’s most challenging universities. We see them in our shuls and neighborhoods. Some of us may even see them in our families.

The problem: whom do we fear the most? Our fears are equally terrifying. We have already lived for years with the devastatingly hateful and evil current regime. It is not good. Not good at all.

But can we survive with those newcomers who despise us, whose hateful diatribes against us and our peoplehood are so laden with untruths and growing animosity? It is not good. Not good at all.

Maybe my paranoia is not misplaced.

Rosanne Skopp of West Orange is a wife, mother of four, grandmother of 14, and great-grandmother of 12. She is a graduate of Rutgers University and a dual citizen of the United States and Israel. She is a lifelong blogger, writing blogs before anyone knew what a blog was! She welcomes email at rosanne.skopp@gmail.com

read more: